Warning: getimagesize(https://durrelliott.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/fullsizeoutput_102d.jpeg): failed to open stream: HTTP request failed! in /home/z65makwnla0j/public_html/wp-content/plugins/td-cloud-library/shortcodes/header/tdb_header_logo.php on line 792

Supreme Court tosses ruling that said Trump blocking Twitter critics was unconstitutional – TechCrunch


The Supreme Court has vacated a previous ruling that found former President Trump violated the First Amendment by blocking his Twitter foes.

The ruling was upheld by a Manhattan federal appeals court in 2019, which deemed Trump’s actions unconstitutional. The court found that because Trump used Twitter to “conduct official business” and interact with the public that his decision to block users ran afoul of the First Amendment.

“… The First Amendment does not permit a public official who utilizes a social media account for all manner of official purposes to exclude persons from an otherwise open online dialogue because they expressed views with which the official disagrees,” a trio of judges wrote in that decision.

The Supreme Court’s decision to vacate the prior ruling isn’t a total surprise — Trump is no longer president and he’s banned from Twitter for life at this point.

What was unexpected was an accompanying opinion issued by Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas which pushed well beyond the issue at hand into novel criticisms of major tech platforms.

Thomas pivoted away from Trump’s Twitter behavior in the 12-page opinion, mounting an argument that the moderation powers of digital platforms like Twitter and Facebook are the real problem. “If the aim is to ensure that speech is not smothered, then the more glaring concern must perforce be the dominant digital platforms themselves,” Thomas wrote.

He went on to raise concerns about “concentrated control” of digital platforms by a handful of decision makers, arguing that digital platforms exercise too much power in making moderation decisions. “Much like with a communications utility, this concentration gives some digital platforms enormous control over speech,” Thomas wrote.

Thomas’s opinion Monday echoed his previous arguments that the protections conferred to digital platforms by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act should be “pared back” and interpreted far more narrowly.

With Democrats at the wheel in Congress, some Republicans have shifted their criticisms of big tech away from its moderation powers and toward other issues, like how those services affect mental health. But the suite of grievances stirred up over the course of Trump’s four years in office lives on in Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas.

In January, Thomas’s wife Ginni Thomas, a fervent Trump supporter, faced criticism for cheering on the pro-Trump crowd that went on to violently invade the U.S. Capitol.

Thomas was not joined by other justices in his opinion, but his interest in tech’s moderation decisions is a signal that the issue is far from dead.

“We will soon have no choice but to address how our legal doctrines apply to highly concentrated, privately owned information infrastructure such as digital platforms,” he warned.



Source link

Get in Touch

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Articles

Climate Change Is the Biggest Story on Earth. So Why Can’t Hollywood Make Good TV Shows and Movies About It?

Last summer, I wrote a short story entitled Rat Island, set in a post-pandemic United States. In it, the rule of law and...

Kathleen Dawson Cracks More than a Second off Scottish 200 Back Record

2021 BRITISH SWIMMING SELECTION TRIALS Kathleen Dawson of the University of Stirling has broken her 2nd Scottish Record of the week at the British...

CSUN, Hawai’i both win in five, MIVA, EIVA, ConfCarolinas into playoffs

GCU's Christian Janke hustles for the ball/GCU athletics ...

Get in Touch

21,815FansLike
2,507FollowersFollow
17,500SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Posts

Climate Change Is the Biggest Story on Earth. So Why Can’t Hollywood Make Good TV Shows and Movies About It?

Last summer, I wrote a short story entitled Rat Island, set in a post-pandemic United States. In it, the rule of law and...

Kathleen Dawson Cracks More than a Second off Scottish 200 Back Record

2021 BRITISH SWIMMING SELECTION TRIALS Kathleen Dawson of the University of Stirling has broken her 2nd Scottish Record of the week at the British...

CSUN, Hawai’i both win in five, MIVA, EIVA, ConfCarolinas into playoffs

GCU's Christian Janke hustles for the ball/GCU athletics ...

College Lacrosse Jerseys – Top 10 Fits in the Men’s Game

College lacrosse jerseys don’t care about wins and losses. You’re going to read a lot of lists that explain who the best teams are...

The 15 Most In-Demand Jobs of the Year

It’s no lie that the job market has become increasingly competitive over the last decade, making it harder to land a job after graduation.  So,...