The NAEP Sounded Red Alert for Students with Disabilities Before Covid-19


The National Assessment of Educational Progress recently released national science results for 2019, and the news disappointed again. The science results reinforced a previous trend in the data—lackluster overall results driven by a disturbing decline in the results for students with disabilities. All six of NAEP’s 4th and 8th grade exams show at least modestly positive trends for students without disabilities between 2009 and 2019. Recent trends among students with disabilities are not nearly so positive (see Figure 1).

Figure 1: NAEP trends 2009 to 2019

 

Notice the consistent pattern of modestly or significantly positive trends for students without disabilities. In three of the six exams (4th grade math, 4th grade reading, and 4th grade science), however, students with disabilities saw statistically significant declines, while their peers without disabilities saw significant improvement. Only 8th grade science defied the trend with increases for both groups between 2009 and 2019.

The scores reported for students with disabilities can be influenced by changes in the share of students who are excluded from NAEP testing altogether, as well as by any changes in the share of students with disabilities provided with testing accommodations. On the science exam, the level of special-needs exclusions remained flat between 2009 and 2019, while accommodation rates increased. If anything, these differences favor 2019 over 2009. The math and reading exams saw fewer exclusions and higher accommodation rates over this period, with an ambiguous net impact worthy of deeper investigation.

There is nothing inevitable about a decline in scores for students with disabilities. Contrary to commonly held stereotypes, a very large majority of students with disabilities do not have a condition that precludes academic progress. In providing additional federal and state funding for students with disabilities, we hope to equalize opportunity and overcome challenges.

We have clear historical examples of large surges in academic achievement for students with disabilities at the state level documented in the NAEP, with Florida serving as a prominent example. It is also worth bearing in mind that the Obama administration’s stimulus package passed early in 2009 (also the first year of the current NAEP science exams and thus the start of the period analyzed here) included a substantial increase in federal special education funding. As we will see below, there are examples of both high-spending states with large declines in achievement for students with disabilities, and relatively modestly spending states with large improvements.

Unlike the 2019 science tests, the NAEP math and reading tests produce state-level results. Figure 2 presents the trends for students with disabilities in 4th grade math and reading between 2009 and 2019 by state. On the math and reading exams, 10 points approximately equals an average grade level’s worth of progress, such that we would expect a group of 5th graders to score approximately 10 points higher than 4th graders. Smaller state samples mean that subgroup estimates have a larger margin of error than at the national level; the tables below indicate whether changes presented in the figure are statistically significant. Changes in exclusion and accommodation rates could also influence the results seen in specific states. Most of the observed effects are not small, however. Nor are they positive.

Figure 2: NAEP 4th Grade Math and Reading Trends

 

The 4th grade reading results for students with disabilities declined in many states. The five states with the highest levels of per-pupil spending (New York, Connecticut, New Jersey, Vermont, and Alaska) all saw large declines. No states registered statistically significant gains in 4th grade math or reading between 2009 and 2019 apart from Mississippi (increased in both subjects) and Hawaii (reading only) and Oklahoma (reading only). Table 1 lists the trends for 4th grade math and reading by state for students with disabilities.



Source link

Get in Touch

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Articles

Lauren Lappin Talks Arizona Softball, Olympics, and a Gold Medal Game Preview

In this edition of In The Circle, Eric Lopez talks with New Arizona assistant coach Lauren Lappin. The two discuss her joining the...

‘Endure: Run Woman Show’ – Why You Should See Endure

As a runner who lives in a populous city, I’m used to getting stuck behind someone dragging their suitcase along the sidewalk. I’m...

Olympic Final at 17 ‘Amazing’ Bonus for New Zealand’s Erika Fairweather

Olympic Final at 17 Is ‘Amazing’ Bonus for New Zealand’s Erika Fairweather Erika Fairweather had high if modest hopes of what she could achieve...

Get in Touch

22,044FansLike
2,507FollowersFollow
18,100SubscribersSubscribe

Latest Posts

Lauren Lappin Talks Arizona Softball, Olympics, and a Gold Medal Game Preview

In this edition of In The Circle, Eric Lopez talks with New Arizona assistant coach Lauren Lappin. The two discuss her joining the...

‘Endure: Run Woman Show’ – Why You Should See Endure

As a runner who lives in a populous city, I’m used to getting stuck behind someone dragging their suitcase along the sidewalk. I’m...

Olympic Final at 17 ‘Amazing’ Bonus for New Zealand’s Erika Fairweather

Olympic Final at 17 Is ‘Amazing’ Bonus for New Zealand’s Erika Fairweather Erika Fairweather had high if modest hopes of what she could achieve...

How to Make Money in Volleyball | Join Volleyball Affiliate Programs

One way to make money in volleyball is to join affiliate programs. You can make a dollar or even tens of dollars from...

Dylan Molloy Could Make PLL Debut in Colorado Springs

The PLL returns to regular season play this weekend at Weidner Field in Colorado Springs, Colorado, and so too might Dylan Molloy to...